Depends on your brand of nit-pickery and fan-fickering? Your Fan-Fic is more likely to spend large chunks of text on detail, or your nit-picking is about character motivations and dialogue rather than physical details. The difference between "Spock would never say that" and "Kirk's shirt was torn in scene 12 but then was miraculously repaired by scene 14, then back to being ripped at the top of the second act".

So for you... which was it? Team Stein or Team Pike?