Super Glue is aparently NOT the answer?

[captain_slinky]

So, uhn... when you're gluing a Pewter Mini together (like the type you use for Gaming that USED to be made of Lead)... what do you use to glue it together? I've been trying to use Super Glue ("Works Great On Metal" according to the package hyperbole) and it says it should have bonded within 15 seconds, but...

...Well, it's just not working out.

Suggestions? Hints? Tips? Insider secrets? Any advice is greatly appreciated!